BORN AGAIN DAILY · PRINT-FRIENDLY DISCUSSION WORKSHEET

How to Check a Bible Claim Before You Share It

A dramatic quote can sound biblical without being in the Bible, and an authentic verse can still be misunderstood. Five checks help you investigate without becoming cynical.

Start the conversation

Copy the exact claim. Is it a direct quotation, interpretation, alleged historical discovery, or application to modern life? Those are different kinds of statements requiring different evidence.

Practical next steps

Find the passage in a Bible, then read the whole paragraph or chapter. Ask who speaks, who listens, and what problem the author addresses.
Compare a second responsible translation if one word is doing all the argumentative work. Check the original-language range if needed, but avoid claiming a dictionary gives you the final meaning.
Trace the claim to its earliest identifiable source. If it quotes a historian or archaeological report, look for the primary source rather than a screenshot or unattributed meme.
Classify your conclusion: directly stated, a plausible interpretation, disputed, or unsupported. Share that distinction with readers instead of exaggerating certainty.

Read Scripture with the group

Acts 17:11 — The Bereans examine the Scriptures when hearing a new claim.
Proverbs 18:17 — An initial account can appear compelling until examined further.

Discuss and respond

What was the last religious claim you repeated without checking the surrounding context? What would you revise today?

Important: Do not present this checklist as proof that your own tradition is immune from error. It is for evaluating our claims as well as others'.