BORN AGAIN DAILY · PRINT-FRIENDLY DISCUSSION WORKSHEET

Why Does the New Testament Have Four Gospels?

Matthew, Mark, Luke and John tell the story of Jesus with overlapping events and different emphases. A reader should hear each voice before trying to combine them into one account.

Start the conversation

Begin with Mark for a brisk narrative, Luke for its attention to historical framing and people at the margins, Matthew for Jesus' teaching and connections to Israel's Scriptures, and John for extended conversations about Jesus' identity.

Practical next steps

1. Read the opening chapter of each Gospel. Compare how each writer introduces Jesus, their audience, and the literary shape of the account.
2. Choose one shared event, such as Jesus feeding the crowd, and examine what each author includes and emphasizes rather than demanding identical wording.
3. Notice that a Gospel is ancient biographical and theological narrative, not a modern verbatim transcript. Distinguish literary selection from factual contradiction.
4. When accounts appear different, write down exactly what each text claims before adopting a proposed harmonization; sometimes the question remains unsettled.

Read Scripture with the group

• Luke 1:1-4 — Luke describes receiving traditions and aiming at an orderly account.
• John 20:30-31 — John explicitly says that his book selects signs for a stated purpose.

Discuss and respond

What do you learn from a Gospel's choices about what to include? How could comparing accounts improve rather than flatten your understanding?

Important: Avoid invented chronological details or claiming that every scholarly disagreement has an easy answer.