A Brighter Day Begins with His Word.

Commenting and Commentaries

Lecture 2: On Commenting

5,377 words

be verbally inspired, and that to the original is the last

appeal.

Fail not to be expert in the use of your Concordance. Every day

I live I thank God more and more for that poor half crazy Alexander

Cruden. Of course you have read his life, which is prefixed to the

concordance; it exhibits him as a man of diseased mind, once or

twice the inmate of a lunatic asylum, but yet for all that

successfully devoting his energies to producing a work of

absolutely priceless value, which never has been improved upon, and

probably never will be; a volume which must ever yield the greatest

possible assistance to a Christian minister, being as necessary to

him as a plane to the carpenter, or a plough to the husbandman. Be

sure you buy a genuine unabridged Cruden, and none of the modern

substitutes; good as they may be at the price, they are a delusion

and a snare to ministers, and should never be tolerated in the

manse library. To consider cheapness in purchasing a concordance is

folly. You need only one: have none but the best. At the head of

each notable word, Cruden gives you its meaning, and very often all

its particular shades of meaning, so that he even helps you in

sermonising. When you have read his headings, by following out the

concordance, you will observe connections in which the word occurs,

which most advantageously and correctly fix its meaning. Thus will

the word of God be its own key. A good textuary is a good

theologian; be then well skilled in using Cruden.

I make but small account of most reference Bibles; they would be

very useful if they were good for anything; but it is extremely

easy to bring out a reference Bible which has verbal and apparent

references, and nothing more. You will often turn to a reference,

and will have to say, "Well, it is a reference, certainly, in a

way, for it contains the same word, but there is no reference in

the sense that the one text will explain the other." The useful

reference cuts the diamond with a diamond, comparing spiritual

things with spiritual; it is a thought reference, and not a word

reference. If you meet with a really valuable reference Bible, it

will be to you what I once heard a countryman call "a reverence

Bible", for it will lead you to prize more and more the sacred

volume. The best reference Bible is a thoroughly good concordance.

Get the best, keep it always on the table, use it hourly, and you

will have found your best companion.

Need I after my previous lectures commend to you the judicious

reading of commentaries! These are called "dead men's brains" by

certain knowing people, who claim to give us nothing in their

sermons but what they pretend the Lord reveals direct to

themselves. Yet these men are by no means original, and often their

supposed inspiration is but borrowed wit. They get a peep at Gill

on the sly. The remarks which they give forth as the Spirit's mind

are very inferior in all respects to what they affect to despise,

namely, the mind of good and learned men. A batch of poems was sent

me some time ago for The Sword and the Trowel, which were written

by a person claiming to be under the immediate influence of the

Holy Spirit. He informed me that he was passive, and that what was

enclosed was written under the direct physical and mental influence

of the Spirit upon his mind and hand. My bookshelves can show many

poems as much superior to these pretended inspirations as angels

are to blue bottles; the miserable doggerel bore on its face the

evidence of imposture. So when I listen to the senseless twaddle of

certain wise gentlemen who are always boasting that they alone are

ministers of the Spirit, I am ashamed of their pretensions and of

them. No, my dear friends, you may take it, as a rule that the

Spirit of God does not usually do for us what we can do for

ourselves, and that if religious knowledge is printed in a book,

and we can read it, there is no necessity for the Holy Ghost to

make a fresh revelation of it to us in order to screen our

laziness. Read, then, the admirable commentaries which I have

already introduced to you. Yet be sure you use your own minds too,

or the expounding will lack interest. Here I call to mind two wells

in the courtyard of the Doge's palace at Venice, upon which I

looked with much interest. One is filled artificially by water

brought in barges from a distance, and few care for its insipid

contents; the other is a refreshing natural well, cool and

delicious, and the people contend for every drop of it. Freshness,

naturalness, life, will always attract, whereas mere borrowed

learning is flat and insipid. Mr. Cecil says his plan was, when he

laid a hold of a Scripture, to pray over it, and get his own

thoughts on it, and then, after he had so done, to take up the

ablest divines who wrote upon the subject, and see what their

thoughts were. If you do not think and think much, you will become

slaves and mere copyists. The exercise of your own mind is most

healthful to you, and by perseverance, with divine help, you may

expect to get at the meaning of every understandable passage. So to

rely upon your own abilities as to be unwilling to learn from

others is clearly folly; so to study others as not to judge for

yourself is imbecility.

What should be the manner of your public commenting? One rule

should be always to point out very carefully wherever a word bears

a special sense; for rest assured in Holy Scripture the same word

does not always mean the same thing. The Bible is a Book meant for

human beings, and therefore it is written in human language; and in

human language the same word may signify two or three things. For

instance, "a pear fell from the tree"; "a man fell into drunken

habits". There the meaning of the second word, "fell", is evidently

different from the first, since it is not literal, but

metaphorical. Again, "the cabman mounted the box"; "the child was

pleased with his Christmas box"; "his lordship is staying at his

shooting box". In each case there is the same word, but who does

not see that there is a great difference of meaning? So it is in

the word of God. You must explain the difference between a word

used in a peculiar sense, and the ordinary meaning of the word, and

thus you will prevent your people falling into mistakes. If people

will say that the same word in Scripture always means the same

thing, as I have heard some assert publicly, they will make

nonsense of the word of God, and fall into error through their own

irrational maxims. To set up canons of interpretation for the Book

of God which would be absurd if applied to other writings is

egregious folly: it has a show of accuracy, but inevitably leads to

confusion.

The obvious literal meaning of a Scripture is not always the

true one, and ignorant persons are apt enough to fall into the most

singular misconceptions--a judicious remark from the pulpit will be

of signal service. Many persons have accustomed themselves to

misunderstand certain texts; they have heard wrong interpretations

in their youth, and will never know better unless the correct

meaning be indicated to them.

We must make sure in our public expositions that obscure and

involved sentences are explained. To overleap difficulties, and

only expound what is already clear, is to make commenting

ridiculous. When we speak of obscure sentences, we mean such as are

mostly to be found in the prophets, and are rendered dark through

the translation, or the Orientalism of their structure, or through

their intrinsic weight of meaning. Involved sentences most abound

in the writings of Paul, whose luxuriant mind was not to be

restrained to any one line of argument. He begins a sentence, and

does not finish it perhaps until eight verses further on, and all

the interstices between the commencement and the end of the

sentence are packed full of compressed truth, which it is not

always easy to separate from the general argument. Hints consisting

of but two or three words will let your hearers know where the

reasoning breaks off, and where it is taken up again. In many

poetical parts of the Old Testament the speakers change; as in

Solomen's Song, which is mostly a dialogue. Here perfect nonsense

is often made by reading the passage as if it were all spoke, by

the same person. In Isaiah the strain often varies most suddenly,

and while one verse is addressed to the Jews, the next may be

spoken to the Messiah or to the Gentiles. Is it not always well to

notify this to the congregation? If the chapters and verses had

been divided with a little common sense, this might be of less

importance, but as our version is so clumsily chopped into

fragments, the preacher must insert the proper paragraphs and

divisions as he reads aloud. In fine, your business is to make the

word plain. In Lombardy I observed great heaps of huge stones in

the fields, which had been gathered out from the soil by diligent

hands to make room for the crops; your duty is to "gather out the

stones", and leave the fruitful field of Scripture for your people

to till. There are Orientalisms, metaphors, peculiar expressions,

idioms, and other verbal memorabilia which arise from the Bible

having been written in the East; all these you will do well to

explain. To this end be diligent students of Oriental life. Let the

geography of Palestine, its natural history, its fauna and its

flora, be as familiar to you as those of your own native village.

Then as you read you will interpret the word, and your flock will

be fed thereby.

The chief part of your commenting, however, should consist in

applying the truth to the hearts of your hearers, for he who merely

comprehends the meaning of the letter without understanding how it

bears upon the hearts and consciences of men, is like a man who

causes the bellows of an organ to be blown, and then fails to place

his fingers on the keys; it is of little service to supply men with

information unless we urge upon them the practical inferences

therefrom. Look, my brethren, straight down into the secret

chambers of the human soul, and let fall the divine teaching

through the window, and thus light will be carried to the heart and

conscience. Make remarks suitable to the occasion, and applicable

to the cases of those present. Show how a truth which was first

heard in the days of David is still forcible and pertinent in these

modern times, and you will thus endear the Scriptures to the minds

of your people, who prize your remarks much more than you imagine.

Clean the grand old pictures of the divine masters; hang them up in

new frames; fix them on the walls of your people's memories, and

their well instructed hearts shall bless you.

Is a caution needed amongst intelligent men? Yes, it must be

given. Be sure to avoid prosiness. Avoid it everywhere, but

especially in this. Do not be long in your notes. If you are

supremely gifted do not be long; people do not appreciate too much

of a good thing; and if your comments are only second rate, why,

then be shorter still, for men soon weary of inferior talking. Very

little time in the service can be afforded for reading the lessons;

do not rob the prayer and the sermon for the sake of commenting.

This robbing Peter to pay Paul is senseless. Do not repeat

commonplace things which must have occurred even to a Sunday School

child. Do not remind your hearers of what they could not possibly

Source & provenance

Original C. H. Spurgeon work; public domain in the United States. Source provenance retained.

View source record