A Brighter Day Begins with His Word.

Commenting and Commentaries

Lecture 2: On Commenting

5,377 words

have forgotten. Give them something weighty if not new, so that an

intelligent listener may feel when the service is over that he has

learned at least a little.

Again, avoid all pedantry. As a general rule, it may be observed

that those gentlemen who know the least Greek are the most sure to

air their rags of learning in the pulpit; they miss no chance of

saying, "The Greek is so and so." It makes a man an inch and a half

taller by a foolometer, if he everlastingly lets fall bits of Greek

and Hebrew, and even tells the people the tense of the verb and the

case of the noun, as I have known some do. Those who have no

learning usually make a point of displaying the pegs on which

learning ought to hang. Brethren, the whole process of

interpretation is to be carried on in your study; you are not to

show your congregation the process, but to give them the result;

like a good cook who would never think of bringing up dishes, and

pans, and rolling pin, and spice box into the dining hall, but

without ostentation sends up the feast.

Never strain passages when you are expounding. Be thoroughly

honest with the word: even if the Scriptures were the writing of

mere men, conscience would demand fairness of you; but when it is

the Lord's own word, be careful not to pervert it even in the

smallest degree. Let it be said of you, as I have heard a venerable

hearer of Mr. Simeon say of him, "Sir, he was very Calvinistic when

the text was so, and people thought him an Arminian when the text

was that way, for he always stuck to its plain sense." A very sound

neighbour of ours once said, by way of depreciating the grand old

reformer, "John Calvin was not half a Calvinist", and the remark

was correct as to his expositions, for in them, as we have seen, he

always gave his Lord's mind and not his own. In the church of St.

Zeno, in Verona, I saw ancient frescoes which had been plastered

over, and then covered with other designs; I fear many do this with

Scripture, daubing the text with their own glosses, and laying on

their own conceits. There are enough of these plasterers abroad,

let us leave the evil trade to them and follow all honest calling.

Remember Cowper's lines--

"A critic on the sacred text should be

Candid and learn'd, dispassionate and free;

Free from the wayward bias bigots feel,

From fancy's influence and intemperate zeal;

For of all arts sagacious dupes invent,

To cheat themselves and gain the world's assent,

The worst is--Scripture warped from its intent."

Use your judgment more than your fancy. Flowers are well enough,

but hungry souls prefer bread. To allegorize with Origen may make

men stare at you, but your work is to fill men's mouths with truth,

not to open them with wonder.

Do not be carried away with new meanings. Plymouth Brethren

delight to fish up some hitherto undiscovered tadpole of

interpretation, and cry it round the town as a rare dainty; let us

be content with more ordinary and more wholesome fishery. No one

text is to be exalted above the plain analogy of faith; and no

solitary expression is to shape our theology for us. Other men and

wiser men have expounded before us, and anything undiscovered by

them it were well to put to test and trial before we boast too

loudly of the treasure trove.

Do not needlessly amend our authorized version. It is faulty in

many places, but still it is a grand work taking it for all in all,

and it is unwise to be making every old lady distrust the only

Bible she can get at, or what is more likely, mistrust you for

falling out with her cherished treasure. Correct where correction

must be for truth's sake, but never for the vainglorious display of

your critical ability. When reading short psalms, or connected

passages of the other books, do not split up the authors utterances

by interjecting your notes. Read the paragraph through, and then go

over it again with your explanations; breaking it up as you may

think fit at the second reading. No one would dream of dividing a

stanza of a poet with an explanatory remark; it would be treason to

common sense to do so: sound judgment will forbid your thus marring

the word of God. Better far never to comment than to cut and carve

the utterances of inspiration, and obscure their meaning by

impertinently thrusting in untimely remarks of your own. Upon many

passages comments would be gross folly: never think of painting the

lily or gilding refined gold; leave the sublime sentences alone in

their glory. I speak as unto wise men; prove your wisdom in this

thing also.

If I were bound to deliver a sermon upon the subject in hand, I

could not desire a better text than Ne 8:8 : "So they read in the

book in the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused

them to understand the reading." Here is a hint for the reader as

to his reading. Let it always be distinct. Aim to be good readers,

and be the more anxious about it because few men are so, and all

preachers ought to be so. It is as good as a sermon to hear our

best men read the Scriptures; they bring out the meaning by their

correct emphasis and tone. Never fall into the idea that the mere

utterance of the words before you is all that is required of you in

reading; good reading is: a high, but rare attainment. Even if you

do not comment, yet read the chapter previously, and become

familiar with it; it is inexcusable for a man to betray the fact

that he is out of his latitude in the reading, traversing untrodden

ground, floundering and picking his way across country, like a

huntsman who has lost his bearings. Never open the Bible in the

pulpit to read the chapter for the first time, but go to the

familiar page after many rehearsals. You will be doubly useful if

in addition to this you "gave the sense." You will then, by God's

blessing, be the pastor of an intelligent, Bible loving people. You

will hear in your meeting house that delightful rustle of Bible

leaves which is so dear to the lover of the Word; your people will

open their Bibles, looking for a feast. The Word will become

increasingly precious to yourself, your knowledge will enlarge, and

your aptness to teach will become every day more apparent. Try it,

my brethren, for even if you should see cause to discontinue it, at

least no harm will come of the attempt.

In all that I have said I have given you another reason for

seeking the aid of the Holy Spirit. If you do not understand a book

by a departed writer you are unable to ask him his meaning, but the

Spirit, who inspired Holy Scripture, lives forever, and he delights

to open up the Word to those who seek his instruction. He is always

accessible: "He dwelleth with you and shall be in you." Go to him

for yourselves and cry, "Open thou mine eyes that I may behold

wondrous things out of thy law"; and, this being granted you,

entreat him to send forth his light and power with the Word when

you expound it, that your hearers also may be led into all truth.

Commentaries, expositions, interpretations, are all mere

scaffolding; the Holy Ghost himself must edify you and help you to

build up the church of the living God.

Source & provenance

Original C. H. Spurgeon work; public domain in the United States. Source provenance retained.

View source record